europa-list
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Amateur-Built Accidents

Subject: Re: Amateur-Built Accidents
From: Robert L. Nuckolls III <nuckolls@aeroelectric.com>
Date: Mon, 10 May 1999 16:50:01
>"According to NTSB, amateur-built airplanes fly less than two percent 
>of the hours yet have ten percent of the accidents. Further, 
>amateur-built airplanes involved in accidents are destroyed 54 
>percent more often than manufactured aircraft and their pilots are 
>killed 88 percent more often"...   
>
>Assuming the facts are as stated, why do you suppose 
>it is so??
>

  I am suspicious of this pronouncement . . . at OSH two 
  years ago, acting administrator Valentine stood on the
  stage at the "Meet the Administrator Meeting" Sunday
  morning and spoke as follows:

  "Amateur built accident rates are on a par with certified
  aircraft. Keep up the good work and we'll stay out of your
  hair."

  I recall viewing this as both a compliment and a threat.
  We could be proud of our accident record but be on notice
  that there are folk within the FAA that would dearly love
  to expand their "helpfulness" into the amateur built world.

  Given that I personally witness that statement and given
  its source, I would REALLY like to see the NTSB pronouncement
  over somebody's signature . . . it wouldn't hurt to have
  access to the source of thier data as well . . . were the
  numbers truly as bad as the quoted paragraph suggest,
  I'd think we'd be building our airplanes to a newly minted
  FAR governing consumer grade aviation . . .


       Bob . . .

                       ////
                      (o o)
       <  Independence Kansas: the     >
       <  Jurassic Park of aviation.   >
       <  Your source for brand new    >
       <  40 year old airplanes.       >
          http://www.aeroelectric.com


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
  • Re: Amateur-Built Accidents, Robert L . Nuckolls III <=